Myślisz, że wymiatasz jeśli chodzi o NBA? Sprawdź się z innymi pasjonatami koszykówki. Odwiedź NBA QUIZ i wykaż się wiedzą!

Ocena wątku:
  • 0 Głosów - 0 Średnio
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Expected Points Added (EPA) is a broken terrible metric.
06-12-2018, 08:15
Post: #1
Expected Points Added (EPA) is a broken terrible metric.
I will now wait here for Ben Baldwin to come swooping into this article to yell at me. Any second now. Ah Duane Brown Jersey , there he is. Good morning! So like I was saying EPA is terrible metric... when looking at punters. Now, I’m not going to dive into some argument about how EPA ignores context of a play formation or some other thing. No, EPA is flawed for punters because it takes into account two things that are absolutely out of the control of the punt team: The decision to punt in the first place.What the yards to go is on the punt attempt. Let’s address the first point: Where on the field should you punt? We could write an entire article about that—and I plan to—but the decision is outside of the realm of what the punter or his coverage team can control. Not accounting for this can lead to some serious EPA penalties if we don’t eliminate it. Should Michael Dickson receive negative EPA because Pete Carroll decides to punt from the opposition’s 45-yard line? Of course not, that hardly makes sense. If you wanted to grade the conservative nature of coaches? Sure, but leave poor Dickson out of these quibbles. Likewise, a decision to punt on 4th and 1—which you should almost never do—will punish the punter all over the field for this decision as seen below. Alright, so now that I’ve convinced you EPA has some flaws in a specific regime, let’s fix them. The fix is actually pretty straight forward. We take every single punt from 2009-2017, lump them together by field position and yards to go, calculate the average for that yardage “bin,” and then we subtract this number from each individual punt in that bin. This will tell us at each specific distance and to go intersection if a punt was above or below average. Now, for the disclaimers! Punting Expected Points Added Yards Adjusted per Punt (PEPAYA/P) extracts out a lot of information about coaches and offense, but it doesn’t remove the effect of having a bad coverage team. This metric is relatively stable year to year (.371 y/y), and correlates strongly to PFF’s grades for punters. But we have a bit of a philosophical problem, because we’re about to dive into the realm of rare events. As you’ve seen me write about before, muffed punts are rare. So far in 2018, about 3% of all punts have been muffed Cheap Shaquem Griffin Jersey , which is actually kind of high compared to some other years. But who do those muffs belong to? If we extract out muffed punts from our data set, we actually lose quite a bit of year over year stability, but it’s unclear that the punter should be given whole credit for these recoveries and drops. To be precise, these are not counted in the same way as fumbles. They are distinctly flagged within the data, as they should be. Same goes for deflections and blocks. Thus far in 2018, there have been no blocks marked in nflscrapR, but two deflections, one of which hurts Michael Dickson’s PEPAYA/P numbers significantly. If we want to look at the punting team as a whole, we should leave in fumbles, deflections, blocks—everything. This way we get a holistic measure of performance. If we want to judge the punter, we should extract out as much non-punter related things as possible, including fumbles, deflections and blocks. The Punting TeamNot accounting for the strength of opposition and purely looking at our PEPAYA/P metric, the Seattle Seahawks are performing as the 7th best punting unit in the league. In general, the Seahawks are generating .25 EPA above average for every distance cross section of punt yardage when you look at the group holistically. That’s actually pretty darn good, and in fact only 20 teams are above zero using this metric. But there is always room for improvement. So far Cheap Jarran Reed Jersey , the punting unit has not generated a fumble, none of Dickson’s punts have been muffed—despite speculation that he would generate an inordinate amount of muffed receiving attempts— and Seattle is one of only two teams to allow a deflected punt. This occurred versus the Rams in Week 5, which actually hurts the team’s per punt numbers significantly and is frustrating, as it came on a blown blocking assignment by Shaquem Griffin and is only one of two deflections out of 803 attempts in 2018. But, since we are looking at the team, team mistakes are fair game. The PunterFeel free to fight me in the comments—you all usually do but I still love you anyways—but I don’t think punters should be rewarded for fumbles or punished for blocks in the vast majority of cases. I do, however, think the punter is at least partially responsible for a muffed catch. But muffs come in many flavors, some are because of a fluttered ball and others because of a quick gunner, or maybe a team’s receiver plays the reception poorly. Separating these out would require assigning at least a percentage of blame on each factor—an arduous task—and one I’m not entirely sure I’m qualified for. But, for the sake of argument, I am going to state that I believe the punter deserves at least some credit. It would also be a bit hypocritical of me to now insist that muffed punts shouldn’t count, after being so excited that Dickson would generate them. The irony is of course that if I exclude muffs, then Dickson is the best punter in the league by this metric. Without further equivocation, your top ten punters with deflections, blocks, and fumbles removed: PEPAYA/P Midterm Grades: Punter A- Bradley McDougald Jersey , Punt Team B+Dickson’s punts are generating a significant amount of expected points added over average for their yardage bins, even more so when we subtract out his one deflection—which was luckily mitigated by one Frank Clark. Thus far, talk that Dickson is not performing well are, to be polite, flat out false. It is true that Dickson could stand to improve, his one shanked punt is evidence of that. It can also be true that he’s not the best punter in the league, and thus far not even the best rookie punter—that would seem to go to Trevor Daniel of the Houston Texans, though PFF disagrees with this, even though in general PFF and PEPAYA/P agree strongly in most cases. If ever there was a case to make that PEPAYA/P too heavily rewards muffed attempts, then Daniel very well could be it. They are, after all, rare events, and he’s had a muffed punt rate four times the league average this year. What will likely happen is that as the year progresses and our samples get larger, we will see PEPAYA/P and PFF converge even more strongly. In the meantime, looking around at all of our available metrics—PFF (11th), PEPAYA/P (3rd), special teams DVOA (8th)—it’s clear that Dickson is having quite the rookie season already Cheap Germain Ifedi Jersey , and his “true” ranking is likely somewhere in that range. So, depending on your priors, Dickson is anywhere from the best to the 11th best punter in the league so far this year. Whether he was worth a fifth round pick (and a trade up) remains to be seen, but in my not so humble opinion he’s certainly on pace.Pete Carroll heaps praise upon the play of Tedric Thompson at free safety The Seattle Seahawks have an ongoing war with Earl Thomas, but Tedric Thompson is doing his best to win the battle.With Thomas continuing to holdout for a new contract or a trade, and Maurice Alexander missing most of training camp due to injuries, Thompson has done enough to earn first-team snaps at free safety over teammate Delano Hill, who would be slotted as a strong safety with Bradley McDougald moving over to free. While Pete Carroll has seemed a little more blunt than usual in his criticisms of players like Germain Ifedi and Alex McGough, he was unrestrained in his compliments for Thompson during an appearance on 710 ESPN on Tuesday morning:Carroll did not call Thompson, “a standout” but “the standout” at a time when Chris Carson is just lighting it up. If Carroll is to be believed — and I’m sure conspiracy theorists would argue he’s just building a stronger case against the need for Earl to return — then perhaps the Seahawks actually have found their free safety of the future. And maybe they don’t feel a need for Thomas to return soon.That being said, I still do expect Earl Thomas to be Seattle’s starting free safety in 2018.No apparent bad blood between the two, Thompson has been saying that Earl is still giving him guidance and advice while away from the team. He may be grooming him now to not replace him somewhere down the line, but immediately. And while nobody could reasonably argue that the Seahawks will be better off with Thompson and McDougald than they were with Thomas and Kam Chancellor, it seems that they’re at least starting to get comfortable with the idea. That wasn’t something a lot of people were saying even a week ago. Now Thompson just needs to ride it out for another month.
Znajdź wszystkie posty użytkownika
Odpowiedz cytując ten post

Podobne wątki
Wątek: Autor Odpowiedzi: Wyświetleń: Ostatni post
  rs3 gold cheap with 6% off &2X loyalty points as Xmas Biggest Promo Dec.12-Dec.18 apple666 0 18 07-12-2018 07:23
Ostatni post: apple666
  What is the hardness range of the cone crusher that can be broken? xuanxuankuaile 0 20 20-11-2018 07:33
Ostatni post: xuanxuankuaile
  These three points must be made before the cutting piece is officially ground. xzbbvfvbh 0 28 01-11-2018 07:52
Ostatni post: xzbbvfvbh
  Buffalo grass receipts added annual greater line adventure on support meant designed baidai8300 0 193 17-08-2018 07:54
Ostatni post: baidai8300
  Raymond Mill points need to pay attention xuanxuankuaile 0 62 20-06-2018 04:06
Ostatni post: xuanxuankuaile
  When buying a sand maker, points to note xuanxuankuaile 0 44 07-06-2018 02:41
Ostatni post: xuanxuankuaile
  Everyone at the hotel expected about mom gaxenyl 0 103 07-05-2018 04:24
Ostatni post: gaxenyl
  Portable crusher plant inspection and treatment points xuanxuankuaile 0 84 01-12-2017 03:23
Ostatni post: xuanxuankuaile
  Detailed construction waste disposal equipment broken process xuanxuankuaile 0 117 20-09-2017 03:02
Ostatni post: xuanxuankuaile
  SBM crusher quality and cheap broken effect xuanxuankuaile 0 70 19-09-2017 04:21
Ostatni post: xuanxuankuaile

Skocz do:

Użytkownicy przeglądający ten wątek: 1 gości